Dick's Sporting Goods Review

(If you'd like to skip this article and see our top pick for a memorabilia retailer, click here.) We’re a nationwide group of memorabilia enthusiasts who created this Website to protect and inform consumers. It's estimated that over half of all memorabilia on the market is fake. With this in mind, our goal is to ensure people buy items that are both authentic and well-priced.

Overview

Dick's Sporting Goods is one of the best-known names in sports equipment. Memorabilia hunters, however, may want to look somewhere else — DicksSportingGoods.com doesn’t have a large memorabilia section. Only by typing in the terms “signed” or “memorabilia” in the site’s search box can visitors find the Fan Shop Memorabilia page, because it is not accessible through the top-bar navigation.

Once in the Fan Shop Memorabilia section of the site, the search becomes easier. There is a navigation box on the left with links to the big four sports and NCAA teams. Clicking on each will lead visitors to that sport’s homepage, which is where visitors will find all the collectibles associated with that team. There is generally not much, however, as memorabilia sales are not the company's main focus.

Some items include authenticity information in the product description, however, there is no detailed authenticity information provided on the site. All sales on autographed items are final, and fall outside the company's 30-day return policy.

One useful feature on this site is in the “How To” link on the Fan Shop Memorabilia home page. This link brings shoppers to a page that serves as a memorabilia buying guide, which may be of interest to some collectors.

The Good

  • Big selection of sports equipment
  • Original content

The Bad

  • Limited selection of autographed memorabilia
  • No authenticity information

Our top pick for 2008:  SportsMemorabilia.com

SportsMemorabilia.com, which has been selling memorabilia online since 1996, is our top pick across the four fields of authenticity, price, ease of shopping and service.

SportsMemorabilia.com features a comprehensive authenticity guarantee and formal relationships with the major memorabilia wholesalers. All items come from organized athlete signings which were witnessed and logged.

The site is professional, easy to navigate and the one-page checkout is simple to use. They employ HackerSafe, THAWTE and 128-bit SSL to secure online transactions.

Searches on Google and Better Business Bureau for “SportsMemorabilia.com” yielded no negative mentions or complaints against the company. There have been no reported instances where a product was returned for lack of authenticity.

The site ranks #1 in Google’s organic (unpaid) search results for terms like "sports memorabilia" and “memorabilia”. Websites don’t pay for placement in these rankings— they are a reflection of Google’s trust in the site and the Website’s age.

In addition to a nice product assortment, the site includes other resources such as a blog and resource library. Information about the company’s background and founders is easy to find. The SportsMemorabilia.com staff, reached both via 800 number and email, was courteous and knowledgeable.

>>Read more about SportsMemorabilia.com